Textbooks and Teaching Materials in Rural Schools: A Systematic Review
Abstract
This paper presents the results of a research project whose main purpose is to analyse the concept of multigrade teaching resources and the teaching materials used by teachers in rural schools, in particular the role of textbooks. The use and dimensions of teaching materials are studied in order to promote inclusion and learning in multigrade classrooms with children of different ages mixed together. The present systematic review aims to identify and analyse all of the research papers published internationally on teaching resources in rural schools for the Web of Science and Scopus databases (from 1992 to 2021) and Google Scholar (between 2010 and February 2021). Due to the dearth of publications focused on the topic of study, the reviewed articles have broad inclusion and exclusion criteria. This gives relevance and an innovative character to the research, allowing us to objectify the state of the question on multigrade didactic materials and their relation to teaching-learning processes. From a total of 332 research papers in the field of rural multigrade teaching identified for further analysis, only papers that met the inclusion and exclusion criteria and passed all phases of the PRISMA flow diagram were used (N = 33). Some research publications contributed to identifying opportunities and needs, and to suggesting criteria to be taken into account for the selection and creation of materials to promote inclusion and active learning methodologies. The first results show the need to create one’s own materials that analyse the reality of these schools, as well as the need to personalise and adapt printed or digital textbooks and other teaching materials in order to involve the students actively in the learning process and to respond to the needs of rural students in multigrade classrooms.
Downloads
References
Afzalnia, M. (2005). Designing and familiarity with the centers of learning materials and resources. Samt.
Block, D., Carrillo, J., & Reséndiz, L. (2017). Una clase de matemáticas sobre problemas de aplicación, en una escuela multigrado unitaria. Un estudio de caso [A mathematics lesson on application problems in a multigrade unitary school. A case study]. Educación matemática, 29(2), 99–123.
Boix, R., & Bustos, A. (2014). La enseñanza en las aulas multigrado: Una aproximación a las actividades escolares y los recursos didácticos desde la perspectiva del profesorado [Teaching in multigrade classrooms: An approach to school activities and teaching resources from a teacher’s perspective]. Revista Iberoamericana de Evaluación Educativa, 7(3), 29–43.
Boix, R., & Domingo-Peñafiel, L. (2019). Escuela graduada y escuela multigrado: una dicotomÃa a superar en el siglo XXI [Graded school and multigrade school: A dichotomy to overcome in the 21st century]. Cuadernos de pedagogÃa, 496, 84–89.
Brown, B. (2010). Multigrade teaching. A Review of Issues, Trends and Practices: Implications for Teacher Education in South Africa. Centre for Education Policy Development (CEPD). Johannesburg, South Africa.
Bustos, A. (2007). Enseñar en la escuela rural aprendiendo a hacerlo. Evolución de la identidad profesional en las aulas multigrado [Teaching in rural schools by learning to teach. Evolution of professional identity in multi-grade classrooms]. Profesorado. Revista de currÃculum y formación de profesorado, 11(3), 1–26.
Bustos, A. (2009). Valoraciones del profesorado de escuela rural sobre el entorno presente [Rural school teachers’ assessments of the present environment]. Revista Iberoamericana de Educación, 48(6), 1–11.
Bustos, A. (2014). La didáctica multigrado y las aulas rurales: perspectivas y datos para su análisis [Multigrade didactics and rural classrooms: Perspectives and data for analysis]. Innovación educativa, 24. https://doi.org/10.15304/ie.24.1994
Carrete-MarÃn, N., & Domingo-Peñafiel, L. (2021). Los recursos tecnológicos en las aulas multigrado de la escuela rural: Una revisión sistemática [Technological resources in rural school multigrade classrooms: A systematic review]. Revista Brasilera de Educaçao do Campo, 6, e13452, 1–31.
https://doi.org/10.20873/uft.rbec.e13452
Cardona, L. A. (2020). Influencia del uso de textos multimodales en las prácticas de escritura en los estudiantes de cuarto y quinto del Centro Educativo Rural Jesús AnÃbal Gómez, sede Patio Bonito [Influence of the use of multimodal texts on the writing practices of fourth- and fifth-grade students at the Jesús AnÃbal Gómez Rural Education Centre, Patio Bonito campus]. http://bibliotecadigital.udea.edu.co/handle/10495/15859
Chaves. L., GarcÃa, J., & Alvarado, R. (2013). Las escuelas unidocentes en Costa Rica: fortalezas y limitaciones [One-teacher schools in Costa Rica: Strengths and limitations. Revista Educación, 37(1), 1–27.
Coaquira, P. (2018). Mejorar uso de recursos y materiales educativos en el desarrollo de sesiones de aprendizaje [Improving the use of educational resources and materials in the development of learning sessions]. http://repositorio.usil.edu.pe/handle/USIL/8286
Coladarci, T. (2007). Improving the yield of rural education research: An editor’s swan song. Journal on Research in Rural Education, 22(3), 1–9.
Cornish, L. (2006). Reaching EFA through multi-grade teaching: Issues, contexts and practices. Kardoorair Press.
Da Silva, C., & Cardoso Filho, I. D. (2017). Rural education and teaching material: An analysis of history textbooks. Revista Brasileira De Educação Do Campo, 3(1), 76–103. https://doi.org/10.20873/uft.2525-4863.2018v3n1p76
Dávila, M. C. (2018). Eco invernadero escolar didáctico como recurso para lograr aprendizajes significativos [Didactic school eco-greenhouse as a resource to achieve significant learning]. University San Ignacio de Loyola. http://repositorio.usil.edu.pe/handle/USIL/7304
Devetak, I., & Ferk Savec, V. (2020). Chemical education research in Slovenia after 1991: A systematic review. CEPS Journal, 10(1), 9–36. https://doi.org/10.26529/cepsj.818
Domingo-Peñafiel, L., & Boix, R. (2015). What can be learned from Spanish rural schools? Conclusions from an international project. International Journal of Educational Research, 74, 114–126. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijer.2015.11.002
Drinkwater, M. (2002). Improve your classroom climate: A workbook for Bed Honours students. Keurkopie.
Fargas-Malet, M., & Bagley, C. (2021). Is small beautiful? A scoping review of 21st-century research on small rural schools in Europe. European Educational Research Journal, 14749041211022202. https://doi.org/10.1177/14749041211022202
Ferguson, D., & Jeanchild, L. (2004). Cómo poner en práctica las decisiones curriculares. In S. Stainback, and W. Stainback, (Eds., Aulas inclusivas: un nuevo modo de enfocar i vivir el currÃculo [Inclusive classrooms: A new way of approaching and experiencing the curriculum] (pp. 21–35). Narcea.
Fernández Palop, M. P., & Caballero GarcÃa, P. A. (2017). El libro de texto como objeto de estudio y recurso didáctico para el aprendizaje: fortalezas y debilidades [The textbook as an object of study and a didactic resource for learning: Strengths and weaknesses]. Revista Electrónica Interuniversitaria de Formación del Profesorado, 20(1), 201–217.
Forero, A., Alemán, L., & Gómez. G. (2016). Experiencias de los docentes en la implementación de las TIC en escuelas rurales multigrado [Teachers’ experiences of ICT implementation in rural multigrade schools]. Edmetic, 5(1), 52–72.
Fraser, J., Loubser, C., & Van Rooy, M. (1993). Didactics for the undergraduate student (2nd ed.). Butterworths.
Garcia, L., & Machado, I. (2017). Recursos didáticos utilizados por professores de escolas rurais de um municÃpio mato-grossense nas décadas de 1980 e 1990 [Didactic resources used by teachers in rural schools in a municipality of Mato Grosso in the 1980s and 1990s]. Educação & Formação, 2(3), 139–152.
GarcÃa Prieto, F. J. (2015). Escuela, medio rural y diversidad cultural en un contexto global: currÃculum, materiales didácticos y práctica docente de Conocimiento del Medio: situación, lÃmites y posibilidades en centros onubenses [School, the rural environment and cultural diversity in a global context: Curriculum, didactic materials and teaching practice in Environmental Knowledge: Situation, limits and possibilities in schools in Huelva] (Doctoral thesis). University of Huelva. http://rabida.uhu.es/dspace/handle/10272/11440
GarcÃa Prieto, F. J., & Pozuelos Estrada, F. J. (2017). El currÃculum integrado: los proyectos de trabajo como propuesta global para una escuela rural alternativa [The integrated curriculum: Project work as a global proposal for an alternative rural school. Aula abierta, 45(1), 7–14.
GarcÃa Prieto, F. J., Pozuelos F. J., & Ãlvarez Ãlvarez, C. (2017). Uso de los libros de texto en la educación rural en España [Use of textbooks in rural education in Spain]. Sinéctica, (49), 1–18.
Genc, Z. (2016). The opinions of primary school teachers’ candidates towards material preparation and usage. Cypriot Journal of Educational Sciences, 11 (2), 70–76.
Giraldo, J., Rosales, A., & Lozano, Y. (2018). 21st Century competencies: How to develop them through the use of video games in a multigrade context? Panorama, 12(23), 7–18.
Guerra, M., Leyva, Y., & Conzuelo, S. (2019). Factores contextuales que afectan la práctica docente desde la perspectiva de docentes de México [Contextual factors that affect teaching practice from the perspective of teachers in Mexico]. Publicaciones: Facultad de Educación y Humanidades del Campus de Melilla, 49(1), 137–149.
Guevara, M. A., Maltez, M. S., & MartÃnez, G. E. (2012). Aplicación de recursos didácticos en la clase de Ciencias Naturales en el sexto grado de educación primaria en la Escuela Rural Los Laureles del turno matutino del Departamento de Chinandega Municipio de Chichigalpa 2011 [Application of didactic resources in the Natural Sciences class in the sixth grade of primary education in the Los Laureles Rural School, morning shift, Department of Chinandega, Municipality of Chichigalpa 2011]. National Autonomous University of Nicaragua.
http://riul.unanleon.edu.ni:8080/jspui/bitstream/123456789/5638/1/220757.pdf
Ivić, I. (2019). Printed and digital media: Printed and digital textbooks. CEPS Journal, 9(3), 25–49. https://doi.org/10.26529/cepsj.694
Joubert, J. (2010). Multi-grade teaching in South Africa. Commonwealth Education Partnership, 58–62. https://www.cedol.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/58-62-2010.pdf
Juarez, D. (2012). Educación rural en Finlandia: experiencias para México [Rural education in Finland: Experiences for Mexico]. Revista CPU-e, 15, 140–154.
Juela, L. F., & Matailo, B. R. (2015) El auto aprendizaje como metodologÃa alternativa en escuelas multigrado [Self-learning as an alternative methodology in multi-grade schools] [Doctoral thesis] University of Cuenca, Ecuador.
https://repositorioslatinoamericanos.uchile.cl/handle/2250/1130732
Juvane, V. (2005). Redefining the role of multi-grade teaching. In Working document prepared for the Ministerial seminar on education for rural people in Africa: Policy lessons, options and priorities. Addis Ababa, Ethiopia (pp. 7–9).
Little, A. (2005). Learning and teaching in multigrade settings. UNESCO. http://multigrade.ioe.ac.uk/fulltext/fulltextLittle.pdf
López, I. (2011). Aprendizaje del Castellano Utilizando en Cuaderno de Trabajo T'ika Básico de Niños y Niñas del 2° y 3° Grado [Spanish language learning using the T'ika Básico Workbook for 2nd and 3rd grade boys and girls] (Doctoral thesis). National University of Altiplano Puno.
http://repositorio.unap.edu.pe/handle/UNAP/159
Mathot, G. B. (2001). A handbook for teachers of multigrade classes (Vol. 1). UNESCO.
McEwan, P. (2008). Evaluating multigrade school reform in Latin America. Comparative Education, 44(4), 465–483. https://doi.org/10.1080/03050060802481504
Miranda, L. A., Angulo-Hernández, L. M., & Román-López, G. (2018). El programa perfiles, dinámicas y desafÃos de la educación costarricense: una propuesta para la innovación pedagógica y la producción de materiales y recursos didácticos tecnológicos en la Universidad Nacional, Costa Rica [The programme profiles, dynamics and challenges of Costa Rican education: A proposal for pedagogical innovation and the production of technological teaching materials and resources at the National University, Costa Rica]. Revista Electrónica Educare, 22(1), 201–224.
Moher, D., Liberati, A., Tetzlaff, J., Altman, D. G., & Prisma Group. (2009). Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. PLoS medicine, 6(7), 264–269.
Msimanga, M. R. (2019). Managing the use of resources in multi-grade classrooms. South African Journal of Education, 39(3), 1–9.
OECD. (2019). Does attending a rural school make a difference in how and what you learn? In PISA in Focus (Issue 94). OECD. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1787/d076ecc3-en
Petrie, G. M., & Darragh, J. J. (2018). Educative curriculum materials: A promising option for independent professional development. English Teaching Forum, 56(4), 2–15.
Pozuelos, F. J., & Travé, G. (2004). Aprender investigando, investigar para aprender: el punto de vista de los futuros docentes [Learning by researching, researching to learn: The perspective of future teachers]. Investigación en la Escuela, 54, 5–25.
RodrÃguez, Y., & Saavedra, E. (2018). Las TIC: Una oportunidad para fortalecer procesos de enseñanza en el marco del modelo escuela nueva [ICTs: An opportunity to strengthen teaching processes in the framework of the new school model]. Espacios, 39(49), 1–11.
Rahim, B. (2018). School resources and learning outcomes: An empirical study of rural public schools. Excellence in Education Journal, 7(2), 3–41.
Rivas-MartÃnez, S., Navarro, G., Penas, A., & Costa, M. (2011). Biogeographic map of South America. A preliminary survey. International Journal of Geobotanical Research, 1(1), 21–40.
Sağ, R. (2009). Birleştirilmiş siniflarda öğretmen olmak. [Becoming a teacher in multigrade classes]. Elektronik Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi. Electronic Journal of Social Sciences, 8(28), 20–39.
San Pedro, M. B., & López, I. (2017). El profesorado de Ciencias Sociales en contextos rurales de Asturias: concepciones y uso de recursos educativos [Social Science teachers in rural contexts in Asturias: Conceptions and use of educational resources]. Aula Abierta, 45(1), 33–40. https://doi.org/10.17811/rifie.45.1.2017.33-40
Sánchez-Meca, J., & Botella, J. (2010). Revisiones sistemáticas y meta-análisis: herramientas para la práctica profesional [Systematic reviews and meta-analyses: Tools for professional practice]. Papeles del Psicólogo, 31(1), 7–17.
SantamarÃa Pérez, J. G. (2021). Consideraciones sobre los textos escolares para la escuela rural: una revisión bibliográfica [Considerations on textbooks for rural schools: A literature review]. Revista Espaço Do CurrÃculo, 14(2), 1–20.
Santos, L. (2011). Aulas multigrado y circulación de los saberes: especificidades didácticas de la escuela rural [Multigrade classrooms and the circulation of knowledge: Didactic specificities of the rural school]. Profesorado, Revista de currÃculum y formación del profesorado, 15(2), 71–91.
Severiano, J. (2013). El uso de la TecnologÃa en el Aula Multigrado [The use of technology in the multigrade classroom] (Doctoral thesis). Tecvirtual University- Tecnológico de Monterrey.
https://repositorio.tec.mx/handle/11285/619532
Silva, N dos S., Silva, J. D. F. A., & Costa, R. T. (2020). The game in multigrade classes at rural schools: Aid to the adoption of essential rules to life. Educação & Formação, 5(14), 93–114.
Smith, G. (2007). Grounding learning in place. World Watch, 20(2), 20–24.
Smith, G. (2002). Place-based education: Learning to be where we are. Phi Delta Kappan, 83(3), 584–594. https://doi.org/10.1177/003172170208300806
Smith, V., Devane, D., Begley, C. M., & Clarke, M. (2011). Methodology in conducting a systematic review of systematic reviews of healthcare interventions. BMC Medical Research Methodology, 11(1), 15–16.
Terigi, F. (2009). Organización de la enseñanza de los plurigrados de las escuelas rurales [Organisation of the teaching of multigrade rural schools] (Doctoral thesis). Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences (FLACSO). https://repositorio.flacsoandes.edu.ec/handle/10469/1266
Tomlinson, C. A. (2001). Aula diversificada: dar respuesta a las necesidades de todos los alumnos [The diversified classroom: Meeting the needs of all students]. Octaedro.
Torres, G. J., Castillo, E. E., & Torres, D. C. (2019) Fortalecimiento de la enseñanza aprendizaje en el Centro Educativo Rural cumainde el paso de Barbacoas Nariño [Strengthening teaching and learning in the rural educational centre cumainde el paso in Barbacoas Nariño]. University Santo Tomás. https://repository.usta.edu.co/handle/11634/16089
Valderrama, E., Winkler, C., & Schmidt, A. (2011). Utilizing multimedia capabilities of mobile phones to support teaching in schools in rural Panama. Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (pp. 935–944).
http://nixdell.com/classes/Tech-for-the-underserved/valderrama_chi2011.pdf
In order to ensure both the widest dissemination and protection of material published in CEPS Journal, we ask Authors to transfer to the Publisher (Faculty of Education, University of Ljubljana) the rights of copyright in the Articles they contribute. This enables the Publisher to ensure protection against infringement.
