Religious Education as Small ‘i’ Indoctrination: How European Countries Struggle with a Secular Approach to Religion in Schools
This article critically reviews the European religious education landscape and argues that a religious notion of religion prevails in most models, not only in confessional RE but also in integrative models and even in so-called alternative subjects that are compulsory for pupils who do not take part in confessional RE. Thus, schools in Europe provide hardly any chance for pupils to acquire a secular perspective on religion and religious diversity, based on a non-theological study of religion. Furthermore, the explicitly or implicitly religious character, particularly of integrative approaches or obligatory alternative subjects to confessional RE, is frequently hidden or played down. Building on analyses of separative (Germany) and integrative (Norway, England) models of RE, the article argues that carefully distinguishing between religious and secular approaches to religion in school is a serious human right’s issue, not least because only secular approaches may be compulsory. The predominant religious framing of religion – that is always linked to confirming the exceptional position of Christianity among the religions in RE – in combination with an actual lack of secular alternatives creates a climate of what may be called ‘small ‘i’ indoctrination’, i.e., an unquestioned discursive hegemony of a particular (Christian) notion of religion as a frame of reference for almost all education about religion, which is, furthermore, often represented as if it constituted not a particular religious view of religion, but a kind of universal perspective on religion. This results in highly problematic conceptualisations, both of religion in general and individual religions – most visibly in stereotyping ‘other’ religions, that are not complemented with an unbiased secular perspective. Thus, the subject matter religion is widely exempted from the secular approach to education in European schools, while a particular religious perspective on religion is promoted, even in models that are designed for all pupils of a religiously heterogeneous class.
Alberts, W. (2007). Integrative religious education in Europe. A study-of-religions approach [Religion and Reason vol. 47]. Berlin & New York, NY: De Gruyter.
Andreassen, B.-O. (2014). Christianity as culture and religions as religion. An analysis of the core curriculum as framework for Norwegian RE. British Journal of Religious Education, 36(3), 265–281.
Berglund, J. (2013). Swedish religion education - Objective but marinated in Lutheran Protestantism? Temenos. Nordic Journal of Comparative Religion, 49(2), 165–184.
Böckenförde, E.-W. (1976). Staat - Gesellschaft - Freiheit. Studien zur Staatstheorie und zum Verfassungsrecht [State – Society – Freedom: Studies in state theory and constitutional law]. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.
CoRE (Commission on Religious Education). (2018). Final report: Religion and worldviews. The way forward. A national plan for RE. Retrieved from https://www.commissiononre.org.uk/
CoRE (Commission on Religious Education). (2019). A New Vision for Religious Education in Schools. Retrieved from https://www.commissiononre.org.uk/
Cotter, C. R., & Robertson, D. G. (Eds.). (2016). After world religions. Reconstructing religious studies. London, UK: Routledge.
Bundesregierung der Bundesrepublik Deutschland. (2000 ). Grundgesetz für die Bundesrepublik Deutschland [Constitution of the Federal Republic of Germany].
ECHR (European Court of Human Rights). (2007). Case of Folgerø and Others vs. Norway (Application no. 15472/02). Retrieved from http://cmiskp.echr.coe.int/tkp197/view.asp?action=html&documentId=819532&portal=hbkm&source=externalbydocnumber&table=F69A27FD8FB86142BF01C1166DEA398649
ECHR (European Court of Human Rights). ( 2010). European Convention on Human Rights. Strasbourg: Council of Europe.
[ERA] UK Parliament. (1988). Education reform act. London: Her Majesty's Stationery Office.
Freie Hansestadt Bremen. ( 2018). Landesverfassung der freien Hansestadt Bremen vom 21. Oktober 1947 [Constitution of the City of Bremen].
Frank, K. (2010). Schulischer Religionsunterricht. Eine religionswissenschaftlich-soziologische Untersuchung [School religious education. A study-of-religions/sociological study]. Stuttgart: Kohlhammer.
Free State of Bavaria. ( 2014). Constitution of the Free State of Bavaria. Retrieved from https://www.bayern.landtag.de/fileadmin/Internet_Dokumente/Sonstiges_P/BV_Verfassung_Englisch_formatiert_14-12-16.pdf
Grimmitt, M. (2000). Contemporary pedagogies of religious education: What are they? In M. Grimmitt (Ed.), Pedagogies of religious education. Case Studies in the research and development of good pedagogic practice in RE (pp. 24–52). Great Wakering: McCrimmons.
Jackson, R. (2016). Religious education in European organisations, professional associations and research groups. In J. Berglund, Y. Shanneik, & B. Bocking (Eds.), Religious education in a global-local world (pp. 11–33). Cham: Springer.
Jensen, T., & Kjeldsen, K. (2013). RE in Denmark - Political and professional discourses and debates, past and present. Temenos. Nordic Journal of Comparative Religion, 49(2), 185–224.
NKM (Niedersächsisches Kultusministerium). (2017). Werte und Normen: Kerncurriculum für das Gymnasium, Schuljahrgänge 5-10 [Values and norms: core curriculum for the gymnasium, years 5-10]. Hannover: Land Niedersachsen.
NKM (Niedersächsisches Kultusministerium). (2018). Werte und Normen: Kerncurriculum für das Gymnasium – gymnasiale Oberstufe, die Gesamtschule – gymnasiale Oberstufe, das Berufliche Gymnasium, das Kolleg [Values and norms: Core curriculum for the upper secondary school]. Hannover: Land Niedersachsen.
NSchG Niedersächsisches Kultusministerium. ( 2018). Niedersächsisches Schulgesetz [Education Act for Lower Sayxony]. Retrieved from https://www.mk.niedersachsen.de/download/131234/Broschuere_Das_Niedersaechsische_Schulgesetz_NSchG_Stand_Mai_2018.pdf
NSS (National Secular Society). (2017). 21st century RE for All. It’s time to reform religion and belief education. Retrieved from https://www.secularism.org.uk/21st-century-re-for-all/
Reuter, A. (2014). Religion in der verrechtlichten Gesellschaft. Rechtskonflikte um Religion als Grenzarbeiten am religiösen Feld [Religion in a legally regulated society. Litigations on religion as boundary work at the religious field]. Göttingen: V&R.
Rothgangel, M., Jäggle, M., & Schlag, T. (2016). Religious education at schools in Europe. Part 1: Central Europe. Göttingen: V&R unipress (Vienna University Press).
Utdanningsdirektoratet. (2015). Læreplan i kristendom, religion, livssyn og etikk (KRLE) [Curriculum for knowledge of Christianity, religion, philosophies of life and ethics]. Oslo: Utdanningsdirektoratet.
In order to ensure both the widest dissemination and protection of material published in CEPS Journal, we ask Authors to transfer to the Publisher (Faculty of Education, University of Ljubljana) the rights of copyright in the Articles they contribute. This enables the Publisher to ensure protection against infringement.